Look for Me Read online

  ALSO BY LISA GARDNER

  NOVELS

  The Perfect Husband

  The Other Daughter

  The Third Victim

  The Next Accident

  The Survivors Club

  The Killing Hour

  Alone

  Gone

  Hide

  Say Goodbye

  The Neighbor

  Live to Tell

  Love You More

  Catch Me

  Touch & Go

  Fear Nothing

  Crash & Burn

  Find Her

  SHORT WORKS

  The 7th Month

  3 Truths and a Lie

  The 4th Man

  An imprint of Penguin Random House LLC

  375 Hudson Street

  New York, New York 10014

  Copyright © 2018 by Lisa Gardner, Inc.

  Penguin supports copyright. Copyright fuels creativity, encourages diverse voices, promotes free speech, and creates a vibrant culture. Thank you for buying an authorized edition of this book and for complying with copyright laws by not reproducing, scanning, or distributing any part of it in any form without permission. You are supporting writers and allowing Penguin to continue to publish books for every reader.

  DUTTON and the D colophon are registered trademarks of Penguin Random House LLC.

  LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOGING-IN-PUBLICATION DATA

  Names: Gardner, Lisa, author.

  Title: Look for me : a novel / Lisa Gardner.

  Description: New York, New York : Dutton, [2017]

  Identifiers: LCCN 2017042389| ISBN 9781524742058 (hardback) | ISBN 9781524742065 (ebook) | FICTION / Mystery & Detective / Police Procedural. | GSAFD: Suspense fiction. | Mystery fiction.

  Classification: LCC PS3557.A7132 L65 2017 | DDC 813/.54—dc23

  LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2017042389

  This book is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents either are the product of the author’s imagination or are used fictitiously, and any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, business establishments, events, or locales is entirely coincidental.

  Version_1

  For my own perfectly imperfect family.

  I wouldn’t have it any other way.

  Contents

  Also by Lisa Gardner

  Title Page

  Copyright

  Dedication

  Prologue

  Chapter 1

  Chapter 2

  Chapter 3

  Chapter 4

  Chapter 5

  Chapter 6

  Chapter 7

  Chapter 8

  Chapter 9

  Chapter 10

  Chapter 11

  Chapter 12

  Chapter 13

  Chapter 14

  Chapter 15

  Chapter 16

  Chapter 17

  Chapter 18

  Chapter 19

  Chapter 20

  Chapter 21

  Chapter 22

  Chapter 23

  Chapter 24

  Chapter 25

  Chapter 26

  Chapter 27

  Chapter 28

  Chapter 29

  Chapter 30

  Chapter 31

  Chapter 32

  Chapter 33

  Chapter 34

  Chapter 35

  Chapter 36

  Chapter 37

  Chapter 38

  Chapter 39

  Chapter 40

  Epilogue

  Acknowledgments

  About the Author

  Prologue

  A YEAR LATER, WHAT SARAH remembered most was waking up to the sound of giggling.

  “Shhh. Not so loud! My roommates hate it when I bring boys home. Killjoys need their beauty sleep.”

  “So, no making noises? Like this?” A wolf howl from outside Sarah’s bedroom door.

  Fresh giggling. Then loud thumps as someone, probably Heidi, ran into the coffee table, the couch, the standing lamp.

  “Oh well,” Heidi announced happily. “Quiet was never gonna happen. I’m a screamer and proud of it.”

  A man’s voice: “Knew I picked the right girl at the bar. I like screamers. Always have.”

  More giggling, more thumps.

  Sarah groaned, rolled facedown on her tiny mattress, and pulled her pillow over her head. On the opposite side of the wall, no doubt Christy and Kelly were doing the same. Heidi Raepuro had been a last-minute addition to their apartment. A friend of a friend of a friend, qualified mostly by the fact Heidi was willing to pay extra for her own bedroom, and Sarah, Christy, and Kelly, who’d known one another since freshman year, had really wanted the three-bedroom unit. Walking distance to Boston College, bay windows, hardwood floors, crown molding. When Sarah had first walked into the space, she’d felt like a grown-up. No more minifridge, no more standing-room-only dorm room. No more bare mattress shared with two younger siblings in an overcrowded slumlord’s paradise.

  The long nights studying when the rest of her friends had been out partying or repeating their parents’ drug-fueled mistakes had finally paid off.

  Which was the other reason she’d fallen in love with the brightly lit apartment. Because after spending her entire childhood sharing, sharing, sharing, this place offered her the greatest luxury imaginable: her own room. Granted, it was barely the size of a twin mattress, more a closet than a bedroom, most likely converted by an enterprising landlord looking to charge a three-bedroom price for what was originally a two-bedroom unit, but Sarah didn’t care. Tiny fit her budget. And with Christy and Kelly able to split the largest room, and silly, vapid Heidi cashing out the other main sleeping space, everyone was happy. Especially Sarah, ensconced in her minuscule slice of paradise.

  Except for nights like tonight.

  More crashing—then moaning. Good God, didn’t Heidi ever get enough?

  A curious scrape.

  “Hey now.” Heidi’s voice, hiccupping slightly as she panted from exertion.

  Sarah rolled her eyes, pulled the pillow tighter around her ears.

  “Wait . . . I don’t want . . . No!”

  Sarah sat up just as Heidi screamed. Loud, piercing, and . . .

  Do screams have a taste? Fire? Ash? Red-hot cinnamon candies, which as a little girl Sarah liked to let melt on the tip of her tongue?

  Or is it more that screams have a color? Green and gold giggles, purple and blue cackles, or this? Molten white. Melt-your-eyeballs, singe-the-hair-on-your-arms, bright, bright white? A color too brilliant for nature, searing straight to the core.

  That’s what Heidi screamed. Molten white.

  It pierced the thin walls, threatened to blow out the windows. It jolted Sarah, making her sit bolt upright.

  And completely, totally, unable to move.

  • • •

  THIS WAS THE PART SHE still didn’t remember well. Not even a year later. The police asked her about the details, of course. Detectives, a forensic nurse, later more investigators, crime scene specialists.

  All she could tell them was that the night started with green and gold giggles and ended with molten-white screams. Heidi’s the whitest and brightest but also blessedly short.

  Christy and Kelly. Two girls in one room. Best friends, members of the lacrosse team. Forewarned, forearmed, they fought. They hurled trophies. Was the sound of crashing metal a taste or a color? No, just a crash. Followed
by screams, all kinds of colors and flavors. Fear, rage, anguish. Determination as one nailed him with a lacrosse stick. Horror as he came back with his blade.

  He got Kelly right in the gut (Sarah read the report later), but Kelly got him by the ankles. She rolled herself into him, around him, a human armadillo. And he slashed and he slashed, glancing blows off her ribs, which allowed Christy time to grab the comforter from the lower bunk bed and to throw it at him, tangle up his arms.

  “Sarah!” they were screaming. “Help, Sarah! Nine-one-one, nine-one-one!”

  Sarah called. Another one of those things she didn’t remember, but later she listened to it at her own request. A recording of her voice, trembling, barely a whisper, as she reached the dispatch center: “Help us, please help us, he’s killing them. He’s going to kill us all.”

  She left her room. It had to be done. In her tiny room, she’d be trapped, the proverbial fish in a barrel. She had to get out to open ground.

  To protect herself?

  To save her roommates?

  She didn’t know. A question to ask herself during all the sleepless nights to come.

  She left her room.

  She went toward her roommates’ bedroom. She saw an open hand through the doorway, Kelly’s splayed fingers, and without thinking Sarah grabbed it. Was she going to pull her roommate to safety? Man up and carry each and every one of them out to the hall? No time to think. Just do. So she grabbed Kelly’s hand and pulled hard.

  And found herself holding an arm. Just . . . an arm.

  Because, apparently, when a girl armadilloed herself around a madman’s ankles, sooner or later he got tired of slashing his victim and simply dismantled her instead.

  Screams ahead of her, Christy, still fighting. Followed by a plea behind her.

  “Sarah . . .”

  She didn’t know which way to turn. These sounds, these sights, this night, it didn’t register for her. Couldn’t.

  Slowly she twisted toward the voice behind her, holding Kelly’s warm, wet arm tight against her chest. She found herself face-to-face with Heidi. The girl had crawled from her bedroom. The skin of her naked shoulders appeared silver in the glow of lights through the windows. Unmarred, untouched. But the blonde was hunched forward awkwardly, cradling her stomach, and already Sarah could pick up the whiff of perforated bowels.

  More screaming from the bedroom. Not molten white. Lava red. Pure rage from a star athlete refusing to be cut down in the prime of her life.

  And Sarah knew then what she had to do. She turned away from beautiful, stupid, gutted Heidi. She tightened her grip on poor Kelly’s arm, and she joined the fray.

  Christy, backed into a corner against the bunk bed, armed with her lacrosse stick. Madman, freed from the comforter, dancing around the body splayed at his feet, enjoying himself, taking his time.

  “Excuse me,” Sarah said.

  He darted toward Christy. She swung her stick down. Last minute, he twirled left, jabbed the blade into the soft spot beneath her ribs. A wet, squishing sound, followed by Christy’s hollow grunt. She jerked the stick back, tapped him on the side of his head. Not hard, but he retreated.

  No screaming now. Just the sound of exertion. Everyone breathing hard.

  “Excuse me,” Sarah said again.

  For the first time, the blade man stilled. He turned slightly, a frown on his blood-flecked face. Sarah stared at him. She felt as if she needed to see him. Needed to register him. Or none of this could be real. Especially not this moment, when she held out her hands and offered her friend’s severed arm to the man who’d murdered her.

  Dark hair. High cheekbones. Sculpted face. Exactly the kind of guy Heidi would bring home from a bar. Exactly the kind of guy who would forever be out of Sarah’s league.

  “You forgot this,” she said, still holding out the arm.

  (“What?” the first officer had interrupted. “You said what?”

  “I had to.” Sarah tried explaining to the woman.

  Except maybe there was no explaining such a thing. She’d just known she had to do something. Stop him. Interrupt. Make all those red and white screams go away. So she’d walked into the room, and she’d offered up the only thing she had: Kelly’s bloody arm.)

  He came for her then. Turned fully, blade dripping at his side, lips peeled back from his teeth.

  She watched him advance. She didn’t move. She didn’t scream. She felt like a little girl, standing in the kitchen as her father picked up the boiling teakettle. “What the fuck, you stupid-ass woman? When I ask you for my money, you give me my money! I’m the one in charge here. Now do as I say, or I’ll throw this whole damn pot into your bitch-ugly face. Then we’ll see who’s willing to take care of you after that!”

  Don’t look away, don’t make a sound. This is what she’d learned from her mother over the years. If they’re going to hurt you, make them do it while staring you in the eye.

  Madman halted directly in front of her, blade at his side. She could smell the blood on his cheeks, the whiskey on his breath.

  He said to her: “Scream.”

  As slowly, so slowly, he lifted the knife. Up, up, up.

  Behind him, Christy fumbled with her lacrosse stick. Tried to move. Tried to take advantage. But the stick fell from her trembling fingers. It clattered as she slid down the wall, sank to the floor. A sigh in the distance: no more rage from the star athlete, just acceptance. So this is what it felt like to die.

  “Scream,” he whispered again.

  Sarah stared at him, and in his gaze, she knew exactly what he was going to do. He was not her loser father. Not subject to a quick temper or drunken rages. No, the hunting knife in his hand, the blood on his face. He liked it. Felt no shame, no remorse. Heidi’s screams, Christy’s fight, her own silent stand—this was the most fun he’d had in years.

  “Though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death,” she heard herself whisper, “I will fear no evil.”

  Then she closed her eyes and clutched this last piece of Kelly close, as with a laugh, a chortle of glee, he slashed the knife straight down toward her chest.

  An explosion. Two, three, four, five. More pain, her shoulder, her chest, her throat. He’d stabbed her, she thought, as she collapsed to the ground. No, he’d shot her. But that didn’t make sense . . .

  A ragged sob behind her, followed by the stench of death growing ever closer. Heidi dragged herself across the hardwood floor.

  Holding a small pistol, Sarah noticed now. Heidi had a gun.

  “I’m sorry,” Heidi whispered. She was crying, tears mixing, smearing with the blood on her cheeks. “Never . . . shoulda . . .”

  “Shhh,” Sarah said.

  Heidi put her head on Sarah’s shoulder. Sarah winced; Heidi had shot her while shooting him. But it hardly seemed to matter now. Blood pooling on her throat, blood dripping from her back, so much pain, and yet it seemed far away, abstract.

  The madman was still. The molten screams had ended. Now, there was just this. A final moment.

  Sarah and Heidi both placed their hands on Kelly’s arm.

  “I’m sorry,” Heidi mumbled again.

  Sarah listened to her last gurgling breath.

  “I will fear no evil,” she whispered in the ensuing silence. “I will fear no evil, fear no evil, fear no evil.”

  The police finally burst through the front door. The EMTs rushed to their rescue.

  “Jesus Christ,” the first cop said, coming to a halt in the middle of the apartment.

  “I will fear no evil,” Sarah told the woman.

  And, once more, offered up Kelly’s severed arm.

  • • •

  A YEAR LATER, WHAT SARAH REMEMBERED most was waking up to the sound of giggling.

  • • •

  DO SCREAMS HAVE A TASTE? Fire? Ash? Red-hot cinnamon
candies, which as a little girl Sarah liked to let melt on the tip of her tongue?

  • • •

  “EXCUSE ME. YOU FORGOT THIS.”

  • • •

  SOUND OF GIGGLING. MOLTEN-WHITE SCREAMS.

  • • •

  I WILL FEAR NO EVIL . . .

  • • •

  ONE YEAR LATER, ONE YEAR LATER, one year later . . .

  • • •

  A KNOCK AT THE DOOR. Hard. And then again.

  Sarah bolted awake in her tiny studio apartment. Drenched in sweat, breath ragged. She lay perfectly still, ears straining. Then it came again. Knocking. Pounding. Someone demanding entrance.

  Slowly, she reached for the top drawer of her nightstand. No stashed knife. She couldn’t even look at a blade. No gun. She’d tried, but her hands shook too much. So a canister of pepper spray. Meant to chase off bears when hiking in the woods and available at any outdoor gear or camping store. She had the canisters stashed all over her single-room apartment, in every bag she carried.

  She drew out the canister, sliding off the mattress as the knocking started again.

  She stank. Could smell the reek of her own sweat and terror. Night after night after night.

  Screams did have a color. It was the only thing she truly understood anymore. Screams had a color, and she was now intimately familiar with all the shades of despair.

  “I will fear no evil,” Sarah told herself as she put her eye to the peephole and gazed into the dimly lit hall.

  A lone woman. Late twenties, early thirties maybe. Dressed casually in jeans and a sweatshirt, she looked like someone Sarah should know. Had maybe met once upon a time. Then again, two A.M. was a strange time for a social call.

  “It’s okay.” The woman spoke up, no doubt sensing Sarah’s gaze on her. She held up both hands, as if to prove she was unarmed. “I won’t hurt you.”

  “Who are you?”

  “Honestly? You’re gonna have to open up to find out. That’s part of the deal. I’m here to help you, but you gotta take the first step.”

  “I will fear no evil,” Sarah said, clutching her bear spray tightly.

  “That’s stupid,” said the woman. “World is full of evil. Fear is what keeps us safe.”